This episode sees the return of Ellen to the fleet with the help of the original Boomer. First off, am I the only one who felt close to vomiting at the reunion of Tigh and Ellen? It was nauseous and more off putting than the entire run of the re-imagined Bionic woman! Kate Vernon was one of the saving grace of this poorly written episode. She relishes her role as Ellen and pitches her character at just the right level. Even the confrontation with Caprica before she loses her baby, is beautifully pitched.
The other highlight is Baltar. Having lost his way since New Caprica to the extent of almost being sidelined and brought out for comical value, he gets a moment to shine. Having abandoned Galactica during the 'rebellion' he returns to his wenches to find he has a challenger for the role of their leader. How did he get them back on his side? the promise of big guns to which they all applaud.
As for Adam, he spends the episode stroking the hull of his ship.
Lets ignore some of the glaring plotholes such as the Cylon workforce moisturizing the hull even though, it was Adama's one wish it was an all human workforce, and the obviously over easy escape of Ellen Tigh from the rebel Cylons and concentrate on the positives... ... ... ... ...
In conclusion, I am glad this series is scrapping it's way toward the end in more ways than one. The whole idea of the Galactica falling apart is an intriguing story, but it's realization on screen is disappointing. Given the extent of the damage to some parts of the ship, Adama really needs to have a chat with his repair crews - what the frak have they been doing these last few years? Surely he has a crew as maintenance of the only defense against the enemy should have been vital priority ? So, forgive me when I say I have little sympathy.
Personally, I expected far more from these episodes and if the end wasn't in sight, I would seriously consider whether to continue on.
Goddess of SciFi verdict - 6/10
No comments:
Post a Comment